Our Mission

To serve the highest quality of meals to our customers with kindness and respect.

Upcoming events


 Father's Day June 18TH 

4th of July weekend 2nd to 4th

July 29th

August 8th to 15th

About Us

Born and raised in Buffalo, NY with a love and passion for food. With no restaurant experience he decided to open a pizzeria with restaurant qualities, fresh, homemade recipes and slow cooked foods. So in late fall of 2015, construction began and with the help of family, The Mayors Pizza Plus was born. 

In the spring of 2016 doors finally opened to the public. Family owned and operated with pride. And with support from our customers we hope to be here for decades to come.

Our Story

Copyright © Mathewson Inc.

The Mayors Pizza Plus

2285 Elmwood ave. 

Buffalo, NY 14216